PDA

View Full Version : Giving religion its due respect


Born Free
10th January 2006, 10:32 PM
I picked up a copy of a magazine yesterday entitled What is Enlightement. It has a range of great articles by various quote weighty contributors (Ken Wilbur, Karen Armstrong to name a few I am familiar with), many around the theme of post-religous spirituality.

One interesting point made, was that when most the religions were founded (around 500bc) they marked a marked step forward in mentality. The author argued, for instance, that it is now estimated that the precentage of the population lost then in warfare is believed to have been 20 times (yes, take it in) that of last century.

This argued that public and personal philosophy made major steps forward at that point.

It also argued that we now are in the midst of another shift toward global consciousness.

This once again reminds me of the trap of judging history by todays standards. It is not fair, and is actually quite misleading. The 'Noble Savage' model has got a lot of airplay, and increasingly studies show that it was a better model than reality.

Daryl

bobcat
11th January 2006, 01:11 AM
Yes, I think that religion deserves a ton of respect for the things it gave us. But, I believe, to take religion as literal and definative is to risk losing the things of REAL value within it. That is why I love people like Spong, the post-theists, post-mormons, and anyone else that feels that the greatest benefits of religion come from transcending it, challenging it, and applying it on new levels.

The "Noble Savage" idea reminds me of a book I read by Gregg Easterbrook, entitled "The Progress Paradox: How Life Gets Better While People Feel Worse". He contemplates the fallacy of the "good old days", when the environment was dirtier, disease was rampant, houses were smaller, war was more prevelant, etc. The world is, by most measurements, better now than it was 50 years ago. And yet, people talk with teary eyes about how things used to be. I guess it's just human nature to view our current condition with skepticism, and to long for something different.