PDA

View Full Version : Why are the pews so empty? Oz Catholic Research Findings


Born Free
3rd December 2006, 06:12 PM
From this weekends Sydney Morning Herald.

Sound somewhat familiar, except that MoInc wouldn't have the courage to make the research findings public IMHO!

Bishops vow to win back Mass drop-outs

Linda Morris Religious Affairs Writer
December 2, 2006

DISILLUSIONMENT with the Catholic Church in the wake of sexual abuse scandals has contributed to a steady decline in Mass attendance, a report to the church's 43 bishops says.

It also cites the restricted roles of women in the church, and a feeling that its leaders are "not intelligent, not vibrant and not relevant" as reasons for the decline.

Those who have stopped going to Mass who were interviewed for the church project Disconnected Catholics, published yesterday, complained of the silencing of prominent theologians and other Catholic thinkers, decisions being made without consultation and a church focused on rules, not compassion.

Some said their parish priest promoted an anti-intellectual environment where "his word was law and critical thinking discouraged". Others pointed to their priest's problem with alcohol, sexual indiscretions or abuse as a key reason for not attending Mass.

For some Catholics, faith no longer provided meaning or made sense. However, this was not driven by better education or widening scientific knowledge but a questioning of church teachings, the role of religion in world conflicts and a sense of uncertainty about the meaning of life and the existence of God, the study said.

"They spoke about fear and guilt, saying that these things prevented them from being able to trust in God and reach a more mature faith. Even after they had stopped going to Mass, they continued to feel guilt and to be conscious of a fear of going to hell."

Catholic bishops promised yesterday to learn from the study's findings and use it to form pastoral strategies to reach out to those Catholics who had ceased practising their faith and "chart a way forward".

The bishops noted that many of the study's participants were still open to returning to Mass. Half said they still attended Mass occasionally, and almost one-third said they might return to weekly Mass attendance.

Attendance has been falling in all age groups under 75 but, worryingly for the church, it has identified up to 60,000 young Catholics between the 1991 and 2001 censuses who no longer identified themselves as such.

"The research project is part of our deep and ongoing desire to connect with people who have left the church and to listen to their experiences, so that we might identify ways to reach out to them and welcome them back," the bishops said.

The research on Disconnected Catholics was carried out by the Pastoral Projects Office of the Australian Catholic Bishops Conference and involved interviewing 41 Catholics aged between 29 and 74. Other reasons given for non-attendance included time clashes with sport, work or family, people not feeling welcomed, sheer laziness and unkind gossip.

The report warned that criticising non-attenders for their laziness, lack of faith or respect for legitimate authority would not attract them back to Mass, and if no action was taken now there would be regular Mass attenders who would soon disappear from church life.

Daryl

helemon
3rd December 2006, 07:07 PM
Some said their parish priest promoted an anti-intellectual environment where "his word was law and critical thinking discouraged". Others pointed to their priest's problem with alcohol, sexual indiscretions or abuse as a key reason for not attending Mass.


Good to see we are not alone in the Mormon church. I wonder if a similar phenomenon is occuring in the Evangelical churches especially after the Haggard affair. ;) I also thought it was interesting that Rick Warren and his wife have taken on a more tolerant and proactive perspective with respect to the AIDS issue.

helemon
4th December 2006, 04:48 AM
I happened to turn on the Joyce Meyer show and the guy on the show said only 4% of teens live a "bible based" life.

peter_mary
4th December 2006, 09:37 AM
This kind of thing seems (at least to me...) to be more and more common. It really does make a person wonder if the religious "first world" is finding faith crumbling out from beneath it. At least faith in conventional religious forms.

It will be very interesting to watch this evolve over the next several decades. I wonder...I really do...if we're watching the death of religion? Is it possible? Not that I expect it in my life-time, but could religion as we know it be a failing senior citizen on the world stage?

And how much help has the Bush/Islam conflict contributed to that declining health in religion? I can't help but wonder if their shared zeal has done more to undermine faith in the wake of 9/11 than anything we've seen since the Renaisance?

helemon
4th December 2006, 01:48 PM
And how much help has the Bush/Islam conflict contributed to that declining health in religion? I can't help but wonder if their shared zeal has done more to undermine faith in the wake of 9/11 than anything we've seen since the Renaisance?

I think you are right. I think we are seeing the decline of religion. I think 9/11 has played into this decline but I think the seeds were planted in the Renisance and the fruits of critical thinking and scientific research are becoming more apparent in our lives. In ancient times people turned to the priests to explain their world and heal their ills. With the advances of science people are turning to the doctors and researchers for answers rather than their preachers. I think the grip of people who were raised pre WW II is ending and with them the strict adherence to authority and tradition. In their place are the anti-establishment hippy generation who are more tolerant of world views outside the ones they were raised to believe and they are better educated than their predecessors.

Kids today know all about dinosaurs and evolution whether their parents want them too or not. With increased globalization kids are more likely to have friends from around the globe. They can make friends around the world over the Internet. They can also read all about the problems with their parents religions. The primary value I see of religion these days is as a networking vehicle.

lynsie
4th December 2006, 05:47 PM
The report warned that criticising non-attenders for their laziness, lack of faith or respect for legitimate authority would not attract them back to Mass

Daryl

Well, at least the Catholics figured this one out better than the mormons. Loudly implying in General Conference that all your "less actives" are simply easily offended and need to grow up...probably not the best course of action.

papa
4th December 2006, 06:16 PM
""They spoke about fear and guilt, saying that these things prevented them from being able to trust in God and reach a more mature faith. Even after they had stopped going to Mass, they continued to feel guilt and to be conscious of a fear of going to hell.""

Ah, guilt and fear-what the world needs now, more than ever... :lftl:

helemon
4th December 2006, 07:50 PM
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/LAC.20061204.NOTE04-2/TPStory/TPEntertainment/Movies/
Despite the holiday season, movie-goers generally were not in the mood for The Nativity Story, a tale of Christ's humble birth that debuted modestly with $8-million to come at No. 4.

Snow in the Midwest kept many moviegoers at home, undermining the film's opening, said David Tuckerman, New Line's head of distribution. "The storms in the middle of the country couldn't have hurt us more," Tuckerman said. "It's a movie made for the heartland, and it killed us in the heartland."


So an act of God prevented people from seeing a movie about the son of God? Perhaps people are just not interested in seeing the movie. The snow didn't prevent the entire bible belt from seeing the movie.

puff
4th December 2006, 08:40 PM
I think you are right. I think we are seeing the decline of religion. I think 9/11 has played into this decline but I think the seeds were planted in the Renisance and the fruits of critical thinking and scientific research are becoming more apparent in our lives. In ancient times people turned to the priests to explain their world and heal their ills. With the advances of science people are turning to the doctors and researchers for answers rather than their preachers. I think the grip of people who were raised pre WW II is ending and with them the strict adherence to authority and tradition. In their place are the anti-establishment hippy generation who are more tolerant of world views outside the ones they were raised to believe and they are better educated than their predecessors.

Kids today know all about dinosaurs and evolution whether their parents want them too or not. With increased globalization kids are more likely to have friends from around the globe. They can make friends around the world over the Internet. They can also read all about the problems with their parents religions. The primary value I see of religion these days is as a networking vehicle.if biblical religion dies , then new age religion will come up like scientology , will it really be any better , people want limits and a reason for life , when i told a tbm friend that life does not neccesarily need a reason , she was blown away , i think religion in general will still go on , albeit in down and up cycles , the new age has not stopped muslims living in a medevil state of mind